| green = League Champion | tan = Toilet Bowl Winner | * = Suicide Pool Winner |
| . | 1987 4 of the 6 Charter teams are still in the league with the same name!! |
| 1st | Terre Haute Sandblasters |
| 2nd | Immortals |
| 3rd | Winning Combinations |
| 4th | Sesquipods |
| 5th | Pit Bulls |
| 6th | Alabama Slammers |
|
| . | 1988 |
| 1st | Immortals |
| 2nd | Dead Fish Pimps |
| 3rd | Top Guns |
| 4th | Sesquipods |
| 5th | Winning Combinations |
| 6th | Can-Do Coons |
| 7th | Alabama Slammers |
| 8th | Terre Haute Sandblasters |
|
| . | 1989 |
| . | Green Division |
| 1st | Dead Fish Pimps |
| 2nd | Sesquipods |
| 3rd | Immortals |
| 4th | Terre Haut Sandblasters |
| 5th | Malignant Hemmorhoids |
| . | Gold Division |
| 1st | Two Percenters |
| 2nd | Top Guns |
| 3rd | Winning Combinations |
| 4th | Alabama Slammers |
| 5th | L.D.S |
|
| . | 1990 Toilet Bowl Started |
| . | Green Division |
| 1st | Sesquipods |
| 2nd | Alabama Slammers |
| 3rd | Top Guns |
| 4th | Winning Combinations |
| 5th | Terre Haut Sandblasters |
| . | Gold Division |
| 1st | Immortals |
| 2nd | Two Percenters |
| 3rd | L.D.S |
| 4th | Dave's Dangerous Dawgs |
| 5th | Dead Fish Pimps |
|
| . | 1991 |
| 1st | Alabama Slammers |
| 2nd | Terre Haute Sandblasters |
| 3rd | Top Guns |
| 4th | Widowmakers (Prior LD's) |
| 5th | Immortals |
| 6th | Sesquipods |
| 7th | Winning Combinations |
| 8th | Dead Fish Pimps |
|
| . | 1992 First Repeat Champion |
| . | Green Division |
| 1st | Terre Haute Sandblasters |
| 2nd | Widowmakers |
| 3rd | Winning Combinations |
| 4th | Sesquipods |
| 5th | War Slammers (prior Alabama) |
| . | Gold Division |
| 1st | Kock Spaniels |
| 2nd | Immortals |
| 3rd | Top Guns |
| 4th | Knights who say Neek (Prior DFP) |
| 5th | Champions |
|
| . | 1993 |
| . | Green Division |
| 1st | Terre Haut Sandblasters |
| 2nd | Sesquipods |
| 3rd | Top Guns |
| 4th | Immortals |
| 5th | Champions |
| . | Gold Division |
| 1st | Dave's Dangerous Dawgs |
| 2nd | Alabama Slammers (Prior War) |
| 3rd | Winning Combinations |
| 4th | Fabulous Widowmakers |
| 5th | Knights who say Neek |
|
| . | 1994 |
| . | Green Division |
| 1st | Top Guns |
| 2nd | Sesquipods |
| 3rd | Fabulous Widowmakers |
| 4th | Immortals |
| 5th | Dave's Dangerous Dawgs |
| . | Gold Division |
| 1st | Terre Haut Sandblasters |
| 2nd | Knights who say Neek |
| 3rd | Alabama Slammers |
| 4th | Winning Combinations |
| 5th | Raptors |
|
| . | 1995 |
| . | Green Division |
| 1st | Alabama Slammers |
| 2nd | Dave's Dangerous Dawgs |
| 3rd | Terre Haut Sandblasters |
| 4th | ZZ Smooth Hogs |
| 5th | Sesquipods |
| . | Gold Division |
| 1st | Winning Combinations |
| 2nd | Immortals |
| 3rd | Top Guns |
| 4th | Knights who say Neek |
| 5th | Fabulous Widowmakers |
|
| . | 1996 First Back to Back Champion |
| 1st | Immortals |
| 2nd | Sesquipods |
| 3rd | Winning Combinations |
| 4th | Hokie Dokies (Prior Top Guns) |
| 5th | Million Man Marchers (Prior DDD's) |
| 6th | Fabulous Widowmakers |
| 7th | Alabama Slammers |
| 8th | Shrubbers (Prior Knights) |
|
| . | 1997 |
| 1st | Alabama Slammers |
| 2nd | Fabulous Widowmakers |
| 3rd | Sesquipods |
| 4th | Winning Combinations |
| 5th | Hokie Dokies |
| 6th | Dead Fish Pimps (Prior Shrubbers) |
| 7th | Immortals |
| 8th | Million Man Marchers |
|
| . | 1998 First 3 Time Champion |
| 1st | Immortals |
| 2nd | Alabama Slammers |
| 3rd | Fabulous Widowmakers |
| 4th | Dead Fish Pimps |
| 5th | Top Guns (Prior Hokie's) |
| 6th | Malignant Hemmorhoids |
| 7th | Winning Combinations |
| 8th | Sesquipods |
|
| . | 1999 Tie for 3rd and 7th |
| 1st | Top Guns |
| 2nd | Winning Combinations |
| 3rd | Alabama Slammers |
| 3rd | Fabulous Widowmakers |
| 5th | Sesquipods |
| 6th | Dead Fish Pimps |
| 7th | Waco Wizards (Prior Malignant Hemmie's) |
| 7th | Immortals |
|
| . | 2000 Lowest Seed ever to win Championship |
| 1st | Winning Combinations |
| 2nd | Immortals |
| 3rd | Alabama Slammers |
| 4rd | Fabulous Widowmakers |
| 5th | Waco Wizards |
| 6th | Sesquipods |
| 7th | Dead Fish Pimps |
| 8th | Top Guns |
|
| . | 2001 From last Place to Champion |
| . | Green Division |
| 1st | Dead Fish Pimps |
| 2nd | Waco Wizards |
| 3rd | Mojo Jojo's (Prior Fab Widow) |
| 4th | Stretch Daddy's |
| 5th | Immortals |
| . | Gold Division |
| 1st | Winning Combinations |
| 2nd | Alabama Slammers |
| 3rd | Granite State Gridders (Prior Top Guns) |
| 4th | P.T. Barnums |
| 5th | Sesquipods |
|
| . | 2002 First 4 Time Champion |
| 1st | Mojo Jojos |
| 2nd | Granite state Gridders |
| 3rd | Winning Combinations |
| 4rd | Alabama Slammers |
| 5th | Immortals |
| 6th | Stretch Daddys |
| 7th | Sesquipods |
| 8th | Dead Fish Pimps |
|
| . | 2003 First 5 Time Champion |
| . | Green Division |
| 1st | Sesquipods * |
| 2nd | Winning Combinations |
| 3rd | Mojo Jojo's |
| 4th | Stretch Daddy's |
| 5th | Granite State Gridders |
| . | Gold Division |
| 1st | Alabama Slammers |
| 2nd | Dead Fish Pimps *,** |
| 3rd | Immortals |
| 4th | Rude Hogs |
| 5th | Mutlucks |
|
| . | 2004 |
| . | Green Division |
| 1st | Dead Fish Pimps * |
| 2nd | Fabulous Mojo's (Prior Mojo Jojo's) |
| 3rd | Winning Combinations |
| 4th | Stretch Daddy's |
| 5th | Mutlucks |
| . | Gold Division |
| 1st | Alabama Slammers |
| 2nd | Immortals |
| 3rd | Granite State Gridders * |
| 4th | Sesquipods |
| 5th | Rude Hogs |
|
| . | 2005 |
| . | Green Division |
| 1st | Sesquipods |
| 2nd | Alabama Slammers |
| 3rd | Fabulous Mojo's |
| 4th | Da' Bruisers |
| 5th | Top Guns (Prior Granite St. Gridders) |
| . | Gold Division |
| 1st | Cunning Linguists |
| 2nd | Dead Fish Pimps |
| 3rd | Mukluks |
| 4th | Winning Combinations * |
| 5th | Immortals |
|
| . | 2006 |
| . | Green Division |
| 1st | Winning Combinations |
| 2nd | Sesquipods * |
| 3rd | Mukluks |
| 4th | Top Guns |
| 5th | Alabama Slammers |
| . | Gold Division |
| 1st | Cunning Linguists |
| 2nd | Fabulous Mojo's |
| 3rd | Immortals |
| 4th | Da' Bruisers |
| 5th | Dead Fish Pimps |
|
| . | 2007 |
| . | Green Division |
| 1st | Alabama Slammers |
| 2nd | Sesquipods |
| 3rd | Fabulous Mojo's |
| 4th | Winning Combinations |
| 5th | Underground Hammers |
| . | Gold Division |
| 1st | Immortals |
| 2nd | Top Guns |
| 3rd | Dead Fish Pimps * |
| 4th | Mukluks |
| 5th | Cunning Linguists |
|
| . | 2008 |
| . | Green Division |
| 1st | Underground Hammers |
| 2nd | Winning Combinations |
| 3rd | Dead Fish Pimps |
| 4th | Top Guns |
| 5th | Mukluks |
| . | Gold Division |
| 1st | Alabama Slammers * |
| 2nd | Fabulous Mojo's |
| 3rd | Immortals |
| 4th | Sesquipods |
| 5th | Cunning Linguists |
|
| . | 2009 Back to Back KFL and Toilet bowl Champs |
| . | Green Division |
| 1st | Fabulous Mojo's |
| 2nd | Alabama Slammers |
| 3rd | Immortals |
| 4th | Sesquipods |
| 5th | Clan MacBeans |
| . | Gold Division |
| 1st | Gravy Dawgs |
| 2nd | Top Guns |
| 3rd | Winning Combinations * |
| 4th | Dead Fish Pimps |
| 5th | Mukluks |
|
| . | 2010 |
| . | Green Division |
| 1st | Alabama Slammers |
| 2nd | Winning Combinations |
| 3rd | Immortals |
| 4th | Dead Fish Pimps * |
| 5th | Mukluks * |
| . | Gold Division |
| 1st | Sesquipods |
| 2nd | Top Guns |
| 3rd | Screaming Kocks |
| 4th | Fabulous Mojo's |
| 5th | Gravy Dawgs |
|
| . | 2011 |
| . | Green Division |
| 1st | Sesquipods |
| 2nd | Immortals |
| 3rd | Alabama Slammers |
| 4th | Fabulous Mojos ** |
| 5th | Top Guns |
| . | Gold Division |
| 1st | Gravy Dawgs |
| 2nd | Dead Fish Pimps ** |
| 3rd | Mukluks |
| 4th | Winning Combinations *,** |
| 5th | Screaming Kocks |
|
| . | 2012 First Three-Peat Champion |
| . | Green Division |
| 1st | Alabama Slammers |
| 2nd | Immortals ** |
| 3rd | Winning Combinations |
| 4th | Gravy Dawgs |
| 5th | Mukluks |
| . | Gold Division |
| 1st | Sesquipods * |
| 2nd | Fabulous Mojos |
| 3rd | Screaming Kocks |
| 4th | Top Guns |
| 5th | Dead Fish Pimps |
|
| . | 2013
|
| . | Green Division |
| 1st | Top Guns |
| 2nd | Immortals |
| 3rd | Winning Combinations |
| 4th | Mukluks * |
| 5th | Gravy Dawgs |
| . | Gold Division |
| 1st | Sesquipods * |
| 2nd | Dead Fish Pimps * |
| 3rd | Fabulous Mojos |
| 4th | Alabama Slammers |
| 5th | Screaming Kocks |
|
| . | 2014 Worst regular season record (5-8) to Champion |
| . | Green Division |
| 1st | Immortals |
| 2nd | Dead Fish Pimps * |
| 3rd | Screaming Kocks |
| 4th | Fabulous Mojos |
| 5th | Sesquipods |
| . | Gold Division |
| 1st | Alabama Slammers |
| 2nd | Winning Combinations |
| 3rd | Top Guns |
| 4th | Gravy Dawgs |
| 5th | Mukluks |
|
| . | 2015 |
| . | Green Division |
| 1st | Immortals |
| 2nd | Winning Combinations |
| 3rd | Fabulous Mojos |
| 4th | Screaming Kocks |
| 5th | Mukluks * |
| . | Gold Division |
| 1st | Top Guns |
| 2nd | Alabama Slammers |
| 3rd | Sesquipods |
| 4th | Gravy Dawgs |
| 5th | Dead Fish Pimps |
| . | KFL2 Champion |
| 1st | Kurt Thompson |
|
| . | 2016 First week 17 All-Star Game |
| . | Green Division |
| 1st | Fabulous Mojos | |
| 2nd | Immortals |
| 3rd | Gravy Dawgs |
| 4th | Dead Fish Pimps * |
| 5th | Sesquipods |
| . | Gold Division # |
| 1st | Winning Combos |
| 2nd | Mukluks |
| 3rd | Alabama Slammers |
| 4th | Top Guns and Sons |
| 5th | Screaming Kocks |
| . | KFL2 Champion |
| 1st | Ty Thompson |
|
| . | 2017
|
| . | Green Division # |
| 1st | Top Guns and Sons * |
| 2nd | Immortals |
| 3rd | Dead Fish Pimps |
| 4th | Fabulous Mojos | |
| 5th | Mukluks |
| . | Gold Division |
| 1st | Sesquipods |
| 2nd | Alabama Slammers |
| 3rd | Screaming Kocks |
| 4th | Gravy Dawgs |
| 5th | Winning Combos |
| . | KFL2 Champion |
| 1st | Austin Klein |
|
| . | 2018
|
| . | Green Division |
| 1st | Dead Fish Pimps |
| 2nd | Top Guns and Sons |
| 3rd | Gravy Dawgs |
| 4th | Sesquipods * |
| 5th | Alabama Slammers |
| . | Gold Division # |
| 1st | Winning Combos |
| 2nd | Immortals |
| 3rd | Screaming Kocks |
| 4th | Mukluks |
| 5th | Fabulous Mojos | |
| . | KFL2 Champion |
| 1st | Ryan's Rad Team |
|
| . | 2019 |
| . | Green Division |
| 1st | Gravy Dawgs |
| 2nd | Screaming Kocks |
| 3rd | Dead Fish Pimps |
| 4th | Immortals |
| 5th | Winning Combinations |
| . | Gold Division # |
| 1st | Alabama Slammers |
| 2nd | Fabulous Mojos * |
| 3rd | Mukluks |
| 4th | Sesquipods |
| 5th | Top Gun & Sons |
| . | KFL2 Champion |
| 1st | Kurt Thompson |
|
| . | 2020 Auto Draft - COVID Play for Fun! |
| . | Green/Gold Division |
| 1st | Fabio Mojos * |
| 2nd | Gravy Dawgs |
| 3rd | Screaming Kocks |
| 4th | S |
| 5th | Mukluks |
| 6th | Top Guns and Sons |
| 7th | Immortals |
| 8th | Winning Combos |
| 9th | Dead Fish Pimps |
| 10th | Slam I AM |
| . | KFL2 Champion |
| 1st | TBD |
|
| . | 2021 6 Time Champion Podz! |
| . | Green Division |
| 1st | Gravy Dawgs |
| 2nd | Top Gun & Sons |
| 3rd | PatriotPodz |
| 4th | Fabio Mojos |
| 5th | Alabama Slammers |
| . | Gold Division # |
| 1st | Winning Combinations * |
| 2nd | Goober Peas |
| 3rd | Mukluks |
| 4th | Immortals * |
| 5th | Screaming Kocks |
| . | KFL2 Champion |
| 1st | n/a |
|
| . | 2022 6 time Champion UMS! |
| . | Green Division |
| 1st | ULTRA MAGA SLAM |
| 2nd | Bourbonaters * |
| 3rd | Sesquipods |
| 4th | Top Gun and Sons |
| 5th | Mighty Pythons |
| . | Gold Division # |
| 1st | 2000 Mojos |
| 2nd | Goober Peas |
| 3rd | Gravy Dawgs |
| 4th | Winning Combinations |
| 5th | Immortals |
| . | KFL2 Champion |
| 1st | n/a |
|
| . | 2023 First time Guillotine Pool |
| . | Green Division |
| 1st | Goober Peas |
| 2nd | Bourbonaters |
| 3rd | PatriotPodzs |
| 4th | Mighty Pythons |
| 5th | ULTRA MAGA SLAM |
| . | Gold Division # |
| 1st | Top Gun and Sons |
| 2nd | Immortals |
| 3rd | Gravy Dawgs |
| 4th | 2000 Mojos |
| 5th | Winning Combinations |
| . | Guillotine Pool Champ |
| 1st | Top Gun and Sons |
|
| . | 2024 Record 4 way W/L (8-6) tie for first place in Gold Division! 6 time champion Immortals! |
| . | Green Division |
| 1st | Immortals |
| 2nd | Gravy Dawgs |
| 3rd | ULTRA MAGA SLAM * |
| 4th | PatriotPodzs |
| 5th | Fabulous Mojos |
| . | Gold Division # |
| 1st | Top Guns and Sons * |
| 2nd | Goober Peas |
| 3rd | The Bourbonater |
| 4th | Winning Combinations |
| 5th | Mighty Pythons |
| . | Guillotine Pool Champ |
| 1st | ULTRA MAGA SLAM |
|